Chern-Gap Monitor for Finite-Horizon Collapse / bench_output.json

Mechanism confirmed, baseline not beaten

Raw ⬇ ZIP
  1{
  2  "bench_version": 1,
  3  "track": "dynamics",
  4  "model": "rnn_small",
  5  "metric_direction": "lower is better",
  6  "n_seeds": 8,
  7  "baseline": {
  8    "best_cfg": {
  9      "lr": 0.003
 10    },
 11    "sweep": [
 12      {
 13        "cfg": {
 14          "lr": 0.001
 15        },
 16        "mean": 1.596962183713913
 17      },
 18      {
 19        "cfg": {
 20          "lr": 0.003
 21        },
 22        "mean": 1.552410066127777
 23      },
 24      {
 25        "cfg": {
 26          "lr": 0.01
 27        },
 28        "mean": 1.5703844726085663
 29      }
 30    ],
 31    "full": {
 32      "mean": 1.5021538734436035,
 33      "std": 0.09324438560832148,
 34      "per_seed": [
 35        1.4778438806533813,
 36        1.4308412075042725,
 37        1.5888422727584839,
 38        1.7121129035949707,
 39        1.4590684175491333,
 40        1.4697362184524536,
 41        1.4667506217956543,
 42        1.4120354652404785
 43      ],
 44      "n": 8
 45    }
 46  },
 47  "idea": {
 48    "mean": 1.5022293776273727,
 49    "std": 0.09287950268012642,
 50    "per_seed": [
 51      1.4786245822906494,
 52      1.4313784837722778,
 53      1.5867565870285034,
 54      1.7121129035949707,
 55      1.459558367729187,
 56      1.4695805311203003,
 57      1.4680730104446411,
 58      1.4117505550384521
 59    ],
 60    "n": 8
 61  },
 62  "comparison": {
 63    "delta_mean": 7.550418376922607e-05,
 64    "idea_wins": 3,
 65    "n_pairs": 8,
 66    "per_seed_diffs": [
 67      0.0007807016372680664,
 68      0.0005372762680053711,
 69      -0.0020856857299804688,
 70      0.0,
 71      0.0004899501800537109,
 72      -0.0001556873321533203,
 73      0.0013223886489868164,
 74      -0.0002849102020263672
 75    ],
 76    "p_value": 0.82525,
 77    "mde": 0.0008536970299377886,
 78    "mde_rel_pct": 0.05683153004696756,
 79    "verdict": "no measurable effect",
 80    "system_worked": false
 81  },
 82  "idea_sweep": [
 83    {
 84      "cfg": {
 85        "lr": 0.003
 86      },
 87      "result": {
 88        "mean": 1.5022293776273727,
 89        "std": 0.09287950268012642,
 90        "per_seed": [
 91          1.4786245822906494,
 92          1.4313784837722778,
 93          1.5867565870285034,
 94          1.7121129035949707,
 95          1.459558367729187,
 96          1.4695805311203003,
 97          1.4680730104446411,
 98          1.4117505550384521
 99        ],
100        "n": 8
101      }
102    },
103    {
104      "cfg": {
105        "lr": 0.001
106      },
107      "result": {
108        "mean": 1.5371521562337875,
109        "std": 0.10299458835449656,
110        "per_seed": [
111          1.533307433128357,
112          1.483575701713562,
113          1.607698917388916,
114          1.7639100551605225,
115          1.5047532320022583,
116          1.5342274904251099,
117          1.4773060083389282,
118          1.3924384117126465
119        ],
120        "n": 8
121      }
122    },
123    {
124      "cfg": {
125        "lr": 0.01
126      },
127      "result": {
128        "mean": 1.5104802548885345,
129        "std": 0.10079049945434744,
130        "per_seed": [
131          1.4905154705047607,
132          1.4462878704071045,
133          1.600508213043213,
134          1.7361385822296143,
135          1.4536124467849731,
136          1.5005030632019043,
137          1.448508620262146,
138          1.4077677726745605
139        ],
140        "n": 8
141      }
142    }
143  ],
144  "track_justification": "dynamics matches stability/control structure of the finite-horizon collapse monitor",
145  "mechanism_signature": {
146    "probe": "trained RNN predictions under three fixed phase perturbations",
147    "per_seed": [
148      {
149        "seed": 0,
150        "baseline_metric": 1.4778438806533813,
151        "idea_metric": 1.4786245822906494,
152        "baseline_gap": 0.0034411137457937002,
153        "idea_gap": 0.005794507451355457,
154        "baseline_chern": 1.7380369271595016e-08,
155        "idea_chern": -4.784160125544356e-10
156      },
157      {
158        "seed": 1,
159        "baseline_metric": 1.4308412075042725,
160        "idea_metric": 1.4313784837722778,
161        "baseline_gap": 0.08322877436876297,
162        "idea_gap": 0.08180162310600281,
163        "baseline_chern": -5.830075504012453e-10,
164        "idea_chern": 2.12119036466648e-09
165      },
166      {
167        "seed": 2,
168        "baseline_metric": 1.5888422727584839,
169        "idea_metric": 1.5867565870285034,
170        "baseline_gap": 0.003892321139574051,
171        "idea_gap": 0.004510408267378807,
172        "baseline_chern": -1.4004964258741766e-09,
173        "idea_chern": -8.674661327411772e-09
174      },
175      {
176        "seed": 3,
177        "baseline_metric": 1.7121129035949707,
178        "idea_metric": 1.7121129035949707,
179        "baseline_gap": 0.08939465880393982,
180        "idea_gap": 0.08939465880393982,
181        "baseline_chern": -6.488612319724056e-11,
182        "idea_chern": -6.488612319724056e-11
183      },
184      {
185        "seed": 4,
186        "baseline_metric": 1.4590684175491333,
187        "idea_metric": 1.459558367729187,
188        "baseline_gap": 0.03839415684342384,
189        "idea_gap": 0.049591924995183945,
190        "baseline_chern": -2.129452757791829e-09,
191        "idea_chern": 5.6372739935792205e-09
192      },
193      {
194        "seed": 5,
195        "baseline_metric": 1.4697362184524536,
196        "idea_metric": 1.4695805311203003,
197        "baseline_gap": 0.10124503821134567,
198        "idea_gap": 0.10104020684957504,
199        "baseline_chern": -4.887011095528017e-09,
200        "idea_chern": -2.0993884286090966e-09
201      },
202      {
203        "seed": 6,
204        "baseline_metric": 1.4667506217956543,
205        "idea_metric": 1.4680730104446411,
206        "baseline_gap": 0.079883873462677,
207        "idea_gap": 0.07974080741405487,
208        "baseline_chern": -9.885893837729884e-09,
209        "idea_chern": 1.0790899473853646e-09
210      },
211      {
212        "seed": 7,
213        "baseline_metric": 1.4120354652404785,
214        "idea_metric": 1.4117505550384521,
215        "baseline_gap": 0.2863689661026001,
216        "idea_gap": 0.28592658042907715,
217        "baseline_chern": 2.0020123666392965e-09,
218        "idea_chern": 6.683505491112086e-11
219      }
220    ],
221    "training_checkpoints_seed0": [
222      {
223        "epoch": 1,
224        "gap": 0.0251762717962265,
225        "chern": 2.9378251026121728e-09,
226        "rounded_chern": 0
227      },
228      {
229        "epoch": 3,
230        "gap": 0.058473870158195496,
231        "chern": 2.4474322762181137e-10,
232        "rounded_chern": 0
233      },
234      {
235        "epoch": 5,
236        "gap": 0.054124489426612854,
237        "chern": -3.3403893006553517e-09,
238        "rounded_chern": 0
239      },
240      {
241        "epoch": 7,
242        "gap": 0.01788416877388954,
243        "chern": -3.5472674164821973e-09,
244        "rounded_chern": 0
245      },
246      {
247        "epoch": 9,
248        "gap": 0.015780657529830933,
249        "chern": -4.577209723398702e-09,
250        "rounded_chern": 0
251      },
252      {
253        "epoch": 10,
254        "gap": 0.005794507451355457,
255        "chern": -4.784160125544356e-10,
256        "rounded_chern": 0
257      }
258    ],
259    "predicted": "Chern stays constant while gap is nonzero; sector changes require gap closing",
260    "observed_transition_count": 0,
261    "min_checkpoint_gap": 0.005794507451355457,
262    "confirmed": true
263  }
264}