Kac-Ward Exact Teacher for Autoregressive Samplers / bench_report.json
Mechanism confirmed, baseline not beaten
1{
2 "bench_version": 1,
3 "track": "planar_ising_autoregressive",
4 "model": "mlp_tiny",
5 "metric_direction": "lower is better",
6 "n_seeds": 8,
7 "baseline": {
8 "best_cfg": {
9 "lr": 0.01,
10 "epochs": 5,
11 "batch": 128
12 },
13 "sweep": [
14 {
15 "cfg": {
16 "lr": 0.001,
17 "epochs": 5,
18 "batch": 128
19 },
20 "mean": 0.1614346206188202
21 },
22 {
23 "cfg": {
24 "lr": 0.003,
25 "epochs": 5,
26 "batch": 128
27 },
28 "mean": 0.13007085770368576
29 },
30 {
31 "cfg": {
32 "lr": 0.01,
33 "epochs": 5,
34 "batch": 128
35 },
36 "mean": 0.12258148938417435
37 }
38 ],
39 "full": {
40 "mean": 0.11785224732011557,
41 "std": 0.017848149462034908,
42 "per_seed": [
43 0.15073059499263763,
44 0.13608941435813904,
45 0.11354892700910568,
46 0.08995702117681503,
47 0.11521363258361816,
48 0.10482487082481384,
49 0.12506559491157532,
50 0.10738792270421982
51 ],
52 "n": 8
53 }
54 },
55 "idea": {
56 "mean": 0.11573431827127934,
57 "std": 0.01748951353530187,
58 "per_seed": [
59 0.14706209301948547,
60 0.1326635181903839,
61 0.11457636952400208,
62 0.09001504629850388,
63 0.10833320766687393,
64 0.09629029035568237,
65 0.12431652843952179,
66 0.11261749267578125
67 ],
68 "n": 8
69 },
70 "comparison": {
71 "delta_mean": -0.0021179290488362312,
72 "idea_wins": 5,
73 "n_pairs": 8,
74 "per_seed_diffs": [
75 -0.0036685019731521606,
76 -0.003425896167755127,
77 0.0010274425148963928,
78 5.8025121688842773e-05,
79 -0.006880424916744232,
80 -0.00853458046913147,
81 -0.0007490664720535278,
82 0.005229569971561432
83 ],
84 "p_value": 0.23005,
85 "mde": 0.003718736254444294,
86 "mde_rel_pct": 3.1554224369971453,
87 "verdict": "no significant win",
88 "system_worked": false
89 },
90 "mechanism_signature": {
91 "prediction": "exact soft conditional labels reduce trained-NN conditional probability MSE versus sampled labels",
92 "baseline_seed0": {
93 "metric": 0.15073059499263763,
94 "q_mse": 0.03577027469873428,
95 "pred_mean": 0.4622843861579895
96 },
97 "idea_seed0": {
98 "metric": 0.14706209301948547,
99 "q_mse": 0.03235262259840965,
100 "pred_mean": 0.4577365219593048
101 },
102 "q_mse_reduction": 0.0034176521003246307,
103 "confirmed": true
104 },
105 "idea_sweep": [
106 {
107 "cfg": {
108 "lr": 0.001,
109 "epochs": 5,
110 "batch": 128
111 },
112 "result": {
113 "mean": 0.17583313025534153,
114 "std": 0.04598349937323497,
115 "per_seed": [
116 0.15006619691848755,
117 0.1609499603509903,
118 0.18380002677440643,
119 0.15149202942848206,
120 0.15694455802440643,
121 0.2921749949455261,
122 0.17385314404964447,
123 0.13738413155078888
124 ],
125 "n": 8
126 }
127 },
128 {
129 "cfg": {
130 "lr": 0.003,
131 "epochs": 5,
132 "batch": 128
133 },
134 "result": {
135 "mean": 0.12854224257171154,
136 "std": 0.01281968850255869,
137 "per_seed": [
138 0.1471148431301117,
139 0.14259950816631317,
140 0.1184714213013649,
141 0.11075853556394577,
142 0.13586729764938354,
143 0.11389961838722229,
144 0.136264368891716,
145 0.12336234748363495
146 ],
147 "n": 8
148 }
149 },
150 {
151 "cfg": {
152 "lr": 0.01,
153 "epochs": 5,
154 "batch": 128
155 },
156 "result": {
157 "mean": 0.11573431827127934,
158 "std": 0.01748951353530187,
159 "per_seed": [
160 0.14706209301948547,
161 0.1326635181903839,
162 0.11457636952400208,
163 0.09001504629850388,
164 0.10833320766687393,
165 0.09629029035568237,
166 0.12431652843952179,
167 0.11261749267578125
168 ],
169 "n": 8
170 }
171 }
172 ],
173 "custom_track": {
174 "name": "planar_ising_autoregressive",
175 "file": "ising_teacher_track.py",
176 "domain": "sequence-level sampling"
177 }
178}