Finite-Splitting Directional Attention / bench_report.json
Mechanism confirmed, baseline not beaten
1{
2 "bench_version": 1,
3 "track": "vision",
4 "model": "directional_cnn",
5 "metric_direction": "lower is better",
6 "n_seeds": 8,
7 "baseline": {
8 "best_cfg": {
9 "lr": 0.001
10 },
11 "sweep": [
12 {
13 "cfg": {
14 "lr": 0.001
15 },
16 "mean": 0.8287499845027924
17 },
18 {
19 "cfg": {
20 "lr": 0.003
21 },
22 "mean": 0.8387499749660492
23 },
24 {
25 "cfg": {
26 "lr": 0.005
27 },
28 "mean": 0.8549999892711639
29 }
30 ],
31 "full": {
32 "mean": 0.8506249710917473,
33 "std": 0.038522525390718286,
34 "per_seed": [
35 0.7999999523162842,
36 0.8849999904632568,
37 0.824999988079071,
38 0.7999999523162842,
39 0.8399999737739563,
40 0.85999995470047,
41 0.9099999666213989,
42 0.8849999904632568
43 ],
44 "n": 8
45 }
46 },
47 "idea": {
48 "mean": 0.8393749892711639,
49 "std": 0.03591983491614504,
50 "per_seed": [
51 0.8149999976158142,
52 0.8849999904632568,
53 0.8050000071525574,
54 0.7749999761581421,
55 0.8399999737739563,
56 0.8700000047683716,
57 0.875,
58 0.8499999642372131
59 ],
60 "n": 8
61 },
62 "comparison": {
63 "delta_mean": -0.011249981820583344,
64 "idea_wins": 4,
65 "n_pairs": 8,
66 "per_seed_diffs": [
67 0.01500004529953003,
68 0.0,
69 -0.019999980926513672,
70 -0.02499997615814209,
71 0.0,
72 0.010000050067901611,
73 -0.034999966621398926,
74 -0.0350000262260437
75 ],
76 "p_value": 0.18755,
77 "mde": 0.016685714835920434,
78 "mde_rel_pct": 1.9615830010850617,
79 "verdict": "no significant win",
80 "system_worked": false
81 },
82 "math_check": {
83 "geometric_ratio": 0.5,
84 "expected_ratio": 0.5,
85 "ratio_allclose": true,
86 "K": 8,
87 "M": 2,
88 "path_split_counts": [
89 3,
90 3,
91 3,
92 3,
93 3,
94 3,
95 3,
96 3
97 ],
98 "max_splits": 3,
99 "N": 3,
100 "bound_holds": true
101 },
102 "idea_sweep": [
103 {
104 "cfg": {
105 "lr": 0.001
106 },
107 "result": {
108 "mean": 0.8487499877810478,
109 "std": 0.04846068349664526,
110 "per_seed": [
111 0.7649999856948853,
112 0.8799999952316284,
113 0.8849999904632568,
114 0.7849999666213989,
115 0.8199999928474426,
116 0.8700000047683716,
117 0.9049999713897705,
118 0.8799999952316284
119 ],
120 "n": 8
121 }
122 },
123 {
124 "cfg": {
125 "lr": 0.003
126 },
127 "result": {
128 "mean": 0.8393749892711639,
129 "std": 0.03591983491614504,
130 "per_seed": [
131 0.8149999976158142,
132 0.8849999904632568,
133 0.8050000071525574,
134 0.7749999761581421,
135 0.8399999737739563,
136 0.8700000047683716,
137 0.875,
138 0.8499999642372131
139 ],
140 "n": 8
141 }
142 },
143 {
144 "cfg": {
145 "lr": 0.005
146 },
147 "result": {
148 "mean": 0.8443749845027924,
149 "std": 0.05405075357696703,
150 "per_seed": [
151 0.8999999761581421,
152 0.7400000095367432,
153 0.8299999833106995,
154 0.8299999833106995,
155 0.7899999618530273,
156 0.8799999952316284,
157 0.8999999761581421,
158 0.8849999904632568
159 ],
160 "n": 8
161 }
162 }
163 ],
164 "custom_track": null,
165 "structural_match": "spatial CIFAR images and convolutional directional fields",
166 "mechanism_signature": {
167 "prediction": "top-2 of K=8 uses 4x fewer directional samples",
168 "K": 8,
169 "beam": 2,
170 "predicted_reduction": 4.0,
171 "observed": [
172 {
173 "seed": 0,
174 "dense_metric": 0.7999999523162842,
175 "routed_metric": 0.7649999856948853,
176 "dense_samples_per_query": 12.0,
177 "routed_samples_per_query": 3.0,
178 "observed_reduction": 4.0,
179 "routing_entropy": 2.0645053386688232
180 },
181 {
182 "seed": 1,
183 "dense_metric": 0.8799999952316284,
184 "routed_metric": 0.8799999952316284,
185 "dense_samples_per_query": 12.0,
186 "routed_samples_per_query": 3.0,
187 "observed_reduction": 4.0,
188 "routing_entropy": 2.0756473541259766
189 }
190 ],
191 "confirmed": true
192 }
193}