Cut-Aware Augmentation Filtering / bench_report.json

Mechanism confirmed, baseline not beaten

Raw ⬇ ZIP
  1{
  2  "bench_version": 1,
  3  "track": "vision",
  4  "model": "cnn_small",
  5  "metric_direction": "lower is better",
  6  "n_seeds": 8,
  7  "baseline": {
  8    "best_cfg": {
  9      "lr": 0.003
 10    },
 11    "sweep": [
 12      {
 13        "cfg": {
 14          "lr": 0.001
 15        },
 16        "mean": 0.8149999976158142
 17      },
 18      {
 19        "cfg": {
 20          "lr": 0.003
 21        },
 22        "mean": 0.7900000065565109
 23      },
 24      {
 25        "cfg": {
 26          "lr": 0.005
 27        },
 28        "mean": 0.8599999994039536
 29      }
 30    ],
 31    "full": {
 32      "mean": 0.8212500065565109,
 33      "std": 0.04414110526102245,
 34      "per_seed": [
 35        0.8050000071525574,
 36        0.7250000238418579,
 37        0.8149999976158142,
 38        0.8149999976158142,
 39        0.8650000095367432,
 40        0.875,
 41        0.8550000190734863,
 42        0.8149999976158142
 43      ],
 44      "n": 8
 45    }
 46  },
 47  "idea": {
 48    "mean": 0.8218750059604645,
 49    "std": 0.042788540285862334,
 50    "per_seed": [
 51      0.8050000071525574,
 52      0.7300000190734863,
 53      0.8149999976158142,
 54      0.8149999976158142,
 55      0.8650000095367432,
 56      0.875,
 57      0.8550000190734863,
 58      0.8149999976158142
 59    ],
 60    "n": 8
 61  },
 62  "comparison": {
 63    "delta_mean": 0.0006249994039535522,
 64    "idea_wins": 0,
 65    "n_pairs": 8,
 66    "per_seed_diffs": [
 67      0.0,
 68      0.004999995231628418,
 69      0.0,
 70      0.0,
 71      0.0,
 72      0.0,
 73      0.0,
 74      0.0
 75    ],
 76    "p_value": 1.0,
 77    "mde": 0.001478123590350151,
 78    "mde_rel_pct": 0.17998460621606582,
 79    "verdict": "no measurable effect",
 80    "system_worked": false
 81  },
 82  "math_check": {
 83    "scale_error": 0.0,
 84    "q_order": false
 85  },
 86  "idea_sweep": [
 87    {
 88      "cfg": {
 89        "lr": 0.001
 90      },
 91      "result": {
 92        "mean": 0.8312499970197678,
 93        "std": 0.04655305473804935,
 94        "per_seed": [
 95          0.7850000262260437,
 96          0.824999988079071,
 97          0.8949999809265137,
 98          0.7549999952316284,
 99          0.8799999952316284,
100          0.8799999952316284,
101          0.8149999976158142,
102          0.8149999976158142
103        ],
104        "n": 8
105      }
106    },
107    {
108      "cfg": {
109        "lr": 0.003
110      },
111      "result": {
112        "mean": 0.8218750059604645,
113        "std": 0.042788540285862334,
114        "per_seed": [
115          0.8050000071525574,
116          0.7300000190734863,
117          0.8149999976158142,
118          0.8149999976158142,
119          0.8650000095367432,
120          0.875,
121          0.8550000190734863,
122          0.8149999976158142
123        ],
124        "n": 8
125      }
126    },
127    {
128      "cfg": {
129        "lr": 0.005
130      },
131      "result": {
132        "mean": 0.8475000038743019,
133        "std": 0.04847678961382153,
134        "per_seed": [
135          0.800000011920929,
136          0.8299999833106995,
137          0.9100000262260437,
138          0.8949999809265137,
139          0.8600000143051147,
140          0.7900000214576721,
141          0.7900000214576721,
142          0.9049999713897705
143        ],
144        "n": 8
145      }
146    }
147  ],
148  "structural_match": "CIFAR image augmentations and CNN prediction graph",
149  "mechanism_signature": {
150    "prediction": "higher estimated cut policy receives lower q",
151    "observed": [
152      {
153        "seed": 0,
154        "baseline": {
155          "metric": 0.8050000071525574,
156          "cuts": [
157            0.8347027159886934,
158            0.8347027159886934,
159            0.9102364030599416
160          ],
161          "q": [
162            0.4159778406556032,
163            0.4159778406556032,
164            0.16804431868879358
165          ],
166          "graph_reg": 0.016758395358920097
167        },
168        "idea": {
169          "metric": 0.8050000071525574,
170          "cuts": [
171            0.8347027159886934,
172            0.8347027159886934,
173            0.9102364030599416
174          ],
175          "q": [
176            0.4159778406556032,
177            0.4159778406556032,
178            0.16804431868879358
179          ],
180          "graph_reg": 0.014007863588631153
181        }
182      },
183      {
184        "seed": 1,
185        "baseline": {
186          "metric": 0.7250000238418579,
187          "cuts": [
188            0.8353256392943406,
189            0.8353256392943406,
190            0.908369077739702
191          ],
192          "q": [
193            0.41386816845062135,
194            0.41386816845062135,
195            0.17226366309875726
196          ],
197          "graph_reg": 0.005923776887357235
198        },
199        "idea": {
200          "metric": 0.7300000190734863,
201          "cuts": [
202            0.8353256392943406,
203            0.8353256392943406,
204            0.908369077739702
205          ],
206          "q": [
207            0.41386816845062135,
208            0.41386816845062135,
209            0.17226366309875726
210          ],
211          "graph_reg": 0.005063352175056934
212        }
213      }
214    ],
215    "confirmed": true
216  },
217  "custom_track": null
218}