Histogram-Controlled Cluster Updates for Iterative GNNs / bench_report.json

Mechanism confirmed, baseline not beaten

Raw ⬇ ZIP
  1{
  2  "bench_version": 1,
  3  "track": "dynamics",
  4  "model": "rnn_small",
  5  "metric_direction": "lower is better",
  6  "n_seeds": 8,
  7  "baseline": {
  8    "best_cfg": {
  9      "lr": 0.01,
 10      "epochs": 12
 11    },
 12    "sweep": [
 13      {
 14        "cfg": {
 15          "lr": 0.001,
 16          "epochs": 12
 17        },
 18        "mean": 0.023774019442498684
 19      },
 20      {
 21        "cfg": {
 22          "lr": 0.003,
 23          "epochs": 12
 24        },
 25        "mean": 0.01013653608970344
 26      },
 27      {
 28        "cfg": {
 29          "lr": 0.01,
 30          "epochs": 12
 31        },
 32        "mean": 0.003741882392205298
 33      }
 34    ],
 35    "full": {
 36      "mean": 0.003835578914731741,
 37      "std": 0.0008182271774829689,
 38      "per_seed": [
 39        0.004058382008224726,
 40        0.003425257047638297,
 41        0.00307759759016335,
 42        0.004406292922794819,
 43        0.004498522728681564,
 44        0.0026040049269795418,
 45        0.005265520885586739,
 46        0.003349053207784891
 47      ],
 48      "n": 8
 49    }
 50  },
 51  "idea": {
 52    "mean": 0.006128221459221095,
 53    "std": 0.0019430310597602655,
 54    "per_seed": [
 55      0.005886178929358721,
 56      0.003636509645730257,
 57      0.005781157873570919,
 58      0.010280938819050789,
 59      0.007521466817706823,
 60      0.0044521004892885685,
 61      0.006602167151868343,
 62      0.004865251947194338
 63    ],
 64    "n": 8
 65  },
 66  "comparison": {
 67    "delta_mean": 0.002292642544489354,
 68    "idea_wins": 0,
 69    "n_pairs": 8,
 70    "per_seed_diffs": [
 71      0.001827796921133995,
 72      0.00021125259809195995,
 73      0.002703560283407569,
 74      0.00587464589625597,
 75      0.003022944089025259,
 76      0.0018480955623090267,
 77      0.0013366462662816048,
 78      0.0015161987394094467
 79    ],
 80    "p_value": 0.0081,
 81    "mde": 0.0014061178480241382,
 82    "mde_rel_pct": 36.65985967916089,
 83    "verdict": "idea worse (significant)",
 84    "system_worked": false
 85  },
 86  "mechanism_signature": {
 87    "track_structure": "controlled pendulum multi-step dynamics; recurrent state updates",
 88    "scheduler": "largest high-bin hidden-state disagreement histogram",
 89    "clusters": 4,
 90    "histogram_bins": 4,
 91    "signature": {
 92      "prediction": "trained-model synchronous-vs-sequential discrepancy scales approximately eta^2",
 93      "rows": [
 94        {
 95          "eta": 0.2,
 96          "observed_linf": 0.023520752787590027,
 97          "eta2": 0.04000000000000001
 98        },
 99        {
100          "eta": 0.4,
101          "observed_linf": 0.09223496913909912,
102          "eta2": 0.16000000000000003
103        },
104        {
105          "eta": 0.6,
106          "observed_linf": 0.20175543427467346,
107          "eta2": 0.36
108        },
109        {
110          "eta": 0.8,
111          "observed_linf": 0.3461129665374756,
112          "eta2": 0.6400000000000001
113        }
114      ],
115      "eta2_ratio_range": [
116        0.5408015102148055,
117        0.5880188196897506
118      ],
119      "confirmed": true
120    }
121  },
122  "runtime_sec": 430.6290466785431,
123  "protocol_notes": {
124    "paired_seeds": [
125      0,
126      1,
127      2,
128      3,
129      4,
130      5,
131      6,
132      7
133    ],
134    "dataset_sizes": [
135      400,
136      100
137    ],
138    "idea_grid": [
139      {
140        "cfg": {
141          "lr": 0.001,
142          "epochs": 12
143        },
144        "mean": 0.2794509418308735
145      },
146      {
147        "cfg": {
148          "lr": 0.003,
149          "epochs": 12
150        },
151        "mean": 0.012458630255423486
152      },
153      {
154        "cfg": {
155          "lr": 0.01,
156          "epochs": 12
157        },
158        "mean": 0.006128221459221095
159      }
160    ],
161    "selected_idea_cfg": {
162      "lr": 0.01,
163      "epochs": 12
164    },
165    "baseline_grid_union": [
166      {
167        "lr": 0.001,
168        "epochs": 12
169      },
170      {
171        "lr": 0.003,
172        "epochs": 12
173      },
174      {
175        "lr": 0.01,
176        "epochs": 12
177      }
178    ]
179  }
180}