Forcing-Consistency Training Constraint / bench_report.json

Mechanism confirmed, baseline not beaten

Raw ⬇ ZIP
  1{
  2  "bench_version": 1,
  3  "track": "dynamics",
  4  "model": "rnn_small",
  5  "metric_direction": "lower is better",
  6  "n_seeds": 8,
  7  "baseline": {
  8    "best_cfg": {
  9      "lr": 0.03,
 10      "weight_decay": 0.0
 11    },
 12    "sweep": [
 13      {
 14        "cfg": {
 15          "lr": 0.01,
 16          "weight_decay": 0.0
 17        },
 18        "mean": 0.0014865802077110857
 19      },
 20      {
 21        "cfg": {
 22          "lr": 0.01,
 23          "weight_decay": 0.0001
 24        },
 25        "mean": 0.0014641905727330595
 26      },
 27      {
 28        "cfg": {
 29          "lr": 0.03,
 30          "weight_decay": 0.0
 31        },
 32        "mean": 0.0012827248574467376
 33      },
 34      {
 35        "cfg": {
 36          "lr": 0.03,
 37          "weight_decay": 0.0001
 38        },
 39        "mean": 0.0013233663485152647
 40      },
 41      {
 42        "cfg": {
 43          "lr": 0.1,
 44          "weight_decay": 0.0
 45        },
 46        "mean": 0.006263854738790542
 47      },
 48      {
 49        "cfg": {
 50          "lr": 0.1,
 51          "weight_decay": 0.0001
 52        },
 53        "mean": 0.014768014312721789
 54      }
 55    ],
 56    "full": {
 57      "mean": 0.0010541816263867076,
 58      "std": 0.0005985854110248448,
 59      "per_seed": [
 60        0.0023917919024825096,
 61        0.0013993943575769663,
 62        0.0006620299536734819,
 63        0.0006776832160539925,
 64        0.0012405221350491047,
 65        0.001023401622660458,
 66        0.000684684026055038,
 67        0.0003539457975421101
 68      ],
 69      "n": 8
 70    }
 71  },
 72  "idea": {
 73    "mean": 0.002501493159797974,
 74    "std": 0.000829447102954745,
 75    "per_seed": [
 76      0.0022331809159368277,
 77      0.001679917797446251,
 78      0.0021533623803406954,
 79      0.003017958952113986,
 80      0.0014837837079539895,
 81      0.003271000226959586,
 82      0.0020722420886158943,
 83      0.0041004992090165615
 84    ],
 85    "n": 8
 86  },
 87  "comparison": {
 88    "delta_mean": 0.0014473115334112663,
 89    "idea_wins": 1,
 90    "n_pairs": 8,
 91    "per_seed_diffs": [
 92      -0.00015861098654568195,
 93      0.00028052343986928463,
 94      0.0014913324266672134,
 95      0.0023402757360599935,
 96      0.00024326157290488482,
 97      0.002247598604299128,
 98      0.0013875580625608563,
 99      0.0037465534114744514
100    ],
101    "p_value": 0.01485,
102    "mde": 0.0011002418315854009,
103    "mde_rel_pct": 104.36928552402951,
104    "verdict": "idea worse (significant)",
105    "system_worked": false
106  },
107  "mechanism_signature": {
108    "math_check": {
109      "js_equal": 0.0,
110      "js_unequal": 0.27539611524877045,
111      "js_symmetric_error": 0.0,
112      "intersection_feasible": true,
113      "intersection_empty": true,
114      "passed": true
115    },
116    "idea_sweep": [
117      {
118        "cfg": {
119          "lr": 0.01,
120          "weight_decay": 0.0,
121          "fc_weight": 0.08,
122          "safety_weight": 0.08
123        },
124        "mean": 0.00227110501145944
125      },
126      {
127        "cfg": {
128          "lr": 0.03,
129          "weight_decay": 0.0,
130          "fc_weight": 0.08,
131          "safety_weight": 0.08
132        },
133        "mean": 0.004607509879861027
134      },
135      {
136        "cfg": {
137          "lr": 0.1,
138          "weight_decay": 0.0,
139          "fc_weight": 0.08,
140          "safety_weight": 0.08
141        },
142        "mean": 0.01652669277973473
143      }
144    ],
145    "best_idea_cfg": {
146      "lr": 0.01,
147      "weight_decay": 0.0,
148      "fc_weight": 0.08,
149      "safety_weight": 0.08
150    },
151    "signature": {
152      "prediction": "FC should lower observational kappa on trained recurrent models",
153      "baseline_kappa_mean": 0.005694788647815585,
154      "idea_kappa_mean": 0.005446167720947415,
155      "baseline_safety_hinge_mean": 0.2168501764535904,
156      "idea_safety_hinge_mean": 0.1869419850409031,
157      "confirmed": true
158    }
159  }
160}